The Yanomamo rules regarding killing are very complicated. It does differ
from western culture but only in general. The Yanomamo regard killing as a more
political act than anything. For example, it mirrors the western culture thought of a deterrent
system of capitol punishment. Where it differs is when the killings that the
Yanomamo commit raise their stature of the individual within the community. In
western culture being known for killing someone does not usually raise the
stature of the individual. In the Yanomamo, being Unokais, is someone who is
very respected and with that respect they are able to have their choice of
mates.
The Yanomamo are very spiritual
and ceremonial in the act of revenge killings. When a headman had been killed
by a raiding party, the body was made into ashes and stored in tiny gourds. The
ashes would be consumed by the women in the village and this was done in a ceremony
to build their men into frenzy. The raiding party of the Yanomamo is small and
is made up of all men. The raiding parties target village is always about a
four day walk from their village. The eve of the attack, the men make an effigy
of the warrior they want to kill. However, the men usually end up killing
whoever they see first. Whatever warrior takes part in the killing must go back
and take part in a ritual cleansing (Unokaimou).
The main benefits of becoming
Unokais in the Yanomamo are increasing your stature within the community. The
Unokais are less likely to have other villagers solicit their wives. In a
kinship of Unokais they are less likely to be a victim of abuse, or to be
looked down upon. The non-Unokais do not have the same privileges as the
Unokais of the village. Although they do not participate in violence, they are
however subjected to have their wives or women in the family have unwanted
advances by Unokais. Being non-unokais sometimes will bring mockery and belittlement
from other tribesman.
To participate in revenge killings
shows other members of the tribe that the individual is willing to fight for
his kinsman and for his rights. This person is elevated within the society as a
person who must be respected. A tribe that is known for revenge killings will
less likely have any other tribe try to attack them. They are able to hold
order through there reputations of killings. The Yanomamo is a transient
community, their membership changes because of migration, emigration, and
fissioning. Unokais who were once tribal members could find themselves in
opposing villages. Yanomama revenge raids can be seen as prominent men inciting
killing raids for their own personal benefit rather than an act of kinship
honor. The kinship dynamic in Yanomamo villages contain paternal decent groups.
There are male and female of all ages that are all related through their
father’s line. These members must find marriage partners through other paternal
line, mainly in their own village. The most prominent men in the tribe know as
"Pata" (Big Ones), usually have polygynous marriage. They can have a
half a dozen wives and many children.
We need rules and laws in any society for it
to function. Any given society can have its own laws that govern them,
depending on their certain situation. There however, should be laws that help
those that can't protect themselves or are forced to participate in actions
which they do not find moral to just protect themselves and their family. In
the article, Jacoby's study it mentions an interesting point. The article says,
“even in societies with law and formal judicial systems and that justice
everywhere has an undeniable element of retribution". With that,
the Yanomamo's reaction to revenge does not seem too far away from our system;
the only difference is that members of the community are responsible for
carrying out justice. The laws that we have in place today help us govern
ourselves without individual action of justice. Laws are very important in any
society to establish order, if justice is sought out by individuals, like the
Yanomamo, it will be a never ending cycle of individuals seeking revenge.
While reading through your post, I realized that I recognized your description of the Yanomamo revenge killings in a cultural aspect of the US, namely the way gang killings in urban areas are used as deterents for further killings and also a way of gaining social status within the group.
ReplyDeleteExcellent line in your last paragraph: "The laws that we have in place today help us govern ourselves without individual action of justice."
Well said. That is precisely the point of the last section. Well done on the post.
I have to agree that there has to be laws in order for a society to function. Even though "most" people do not want to or have not killed people that has to be a law because if anyone could do anything they want knowing there were no laws what makes people sure others wouldn't kill just because maybe they got upset. Or how many people would drink and drive if there was no law against it risking there lives and all the other people on the road.
ReplyDelete